Should You Go For Asphalt Shingles Or Metal Roofing?

Most homeowners go for asphalt shingles for their homes, lured by their low prices and ease of installation compared to metal roofing. However, after dealing with the drawbacks of this type of roofing, they often consider installing metal roofing, which provides a much better alternative.

Asphalt shingles, though popular, come with a whole slew of costly problems, but metal roofing can offer you a longer-lasting and less stressful roofing solution.


Asphalt shingles are quite capable of keeping your home shielded from the elements, but tend to get easily damaged when faced with inclement weather, requiring costly repairs and even replacement after only a few years of service.

This is especially true in hotter weather, where the sun's rays cause asphalt shingles to curl at the edges, crack or get discolored. Rainwater also presents problems, especially if the roof is low pitched and lacks adequate sloping for efficient drainage.

Metal roofing is much tougher and capable of withstanding drastic changes in temperature, high winds, rain and other conditions that would quickly downgrade asphalt shingles. This is mainly because metal roofing is usually protected from the sun's destructive UV rays by a paint that contains inorganic pigments, is more impervious to moisture and can shed snow easier and faster than asphalt shingles.

This allows the roof to last as long as your home itself with a little bit of maintenance, while asphalt shingles need to be replaced after 10 years or so.


Asphalt shingle roofs have been a cheap roofing alternative for the better part of a century, and anyone who has looked at homes with such roofing knows exactly what they offer - poor aesthetics. This is because of the limited designs, shapes and colors offered by asphalt shingles.

Few people outside the roofing business actually know that metal roofs offer the most superior aesthetics of all roofing materials, with designs such as shingles, tiles, diamonds, ribs, panels, and custom shapes to complement any architectural design.

Environmental concerns

Many homeowners are now more environmentally friendly, which makes them shy away from asphalt shingle roofs in favor of metal roofs. This is because asphalt shingles are petroleum-based and non-recyclable, and end up in landfills after being dismantled, where they emit methane gas while decomposing.

Metal roofs are greener due to their superior cooling properties, which allow you to save on energy bills associated with cooling. Metal is also recyclable, which makes it much more environmentally sustainable.

When it comes to longevity, durability, recyclability and need for maintenance, metal has been proven to make significantly better roofing than asphalt roofing shingles. Talk to a roofer like Darr Roofing to learn more.